7 Ways University Educators Can Adopt an Investing Mindset
Whether you are a new faculty member just starting your academic career or a seasoned professor taking on new challenges, today’s educational landscape – with AI, the shift away from tenure, and much more – may feel filled with uncertainty. In essence, the future of higher education is highly unpredictable.
The principles that guide successful evidence-based investing – relying upon rigorous research, diversifying approaches, and maintaining discipline in the face of market volatility – are also informing how we approach education, research, and student development. Just as prudent investors base decisions on peer-reviewed financial research rather than speculation, educators can ground their practice in educational research and data-driven insights. These aren’t rigid rules, but rather evidence-informed ideas that can help educators make thoughtful decisions when the path forward isn’t clear.
1. Diversify Your Educational Portfolio
Just as prudent investors diversify across carefully selected asset classes based on evidence rather than intuition, effective educators diversify their teaching methods based on learning science research. Don’t put all your instructional “investments” in lecture-based approaches – the evidence strongly supports incorporating active learning, collaborative projects, and varied assessment methods. Research from cognitive psychology shows that students learn differently, so a diversified pedagogical portfolio reduces the risk that any single student will be left behind. Like a well-balanced investment strategy, this approach may seem less exciting than betting everything on the latest educational trend, but it produces more consistent, reliable results over time.
2. Base Decisions on Evidence, Not Market Sentiment
Just as evidence-based investors ignore market hype and focus on rigorous financial research, educators should ground their practices in peer-reviewed educational research rather than following the latest pedagogical fads. Before adopting new teaching technologies or methods, ask: What does the research actually show? What are the effect sizes? Have these findings been replicated? Educational “bubbles” come and go – from programmed learning to MOOCs – but evidence-based practices provide steady, reliable returns on your instructional investment. Maintain the intellectual discipline to distinguish between promising innovations supported by data and mere speculation dressed up as progress.
3. Invest in Fundamentals with Proven Track Records
Smart investors favor assets with long histories of solid performance over flashy newcomers. Similarly, educators should invest heavily in fundamental skills that research consistently shows matter: critical thinking, quantitative reasoning, clear writing, and effective communication. These are the educational equivalent of blue-chip stocks—they may not generate exciting headlines, but they provide reliable value across economic cycles and career changes. While you should allocate some effort to emerging skills, the bulk of your curricular “portfolio” should focus on these time-tested competencies that research repeatedly validates as essential for student success.
4. Maintain Discipline During Market Volatility
Evidence-based investors don’t panic during market downturns or chase performance during bull runs – they stick to their research-backed strategy. Educators face similar volatility: budget cuts, enrollment swings, administrative pressures, and technological disruptions. The key is maintaining disciplined focus on what research shows works, regardless of external turbulence. When administrators push for quick fixes or trendy solutions, respond like a prudent portfolio manager: acknowledge the pressures while staying committed to evidence-based practices that may take time to show results but have proven track records of success. New tools and techniques will emerge, and examine the research on their utility carefully, and then test out those which show promise to further your educational mission.
5. Regularly Rebalance Your Approach Based on Data
Disciplined investors periodically rebalance their portfolios based on performance data and changing conditions. Educators should similarly use assessment data, student feedback, and learning analytics to rebalance their instructional approaches. If research shows that certain methods are no longer producing expected learning outcomes, don’t let emotional attachment to familiar practices prevent you from making evidence-based adjustments. Regularly collect and analyze data on student performance, engagement, and retention – then use this information to make informed decisions about where to allocate your instructional energy and resources.
6. Understand that Compound Returns take Time
Evidence-based investing succeeds through patience and compound growth, not quick wins. Educational “returns” work similarly – the benefits of practice with rigorous, research-based teaching practices compound over years, not semesters.
Students may not immediately appreciate being pushed to think critically rather than memorizing answers, just as investors may not appreciate the boring consistency of index funds during exciting market runs. But research consistently shows that students who develop strong foundational skills and learning habits early see accelerating returns throughout their academic and professional careers.
Resist the pressure for immediate dramatic improvements and trust the evidence about long-term educational compound growth.
7. Avoid Speculation – Stick to Your Research-Based Strategy
The most successful investors avoid get-rich-quick schemes and stick to strategies backed by decades of financial research. Similarly, avoid “get-smart-quick” educational schemes that promise revolutionary results without solid evidence. Whether it’s learning styles theory, brain-based learning claims, or the latest educational technology, ask the same questions a prudent investor would: Where’s the peer-reviewed research? What are the replication rates? What do meta-analyses show? Just as evidence-based investors ignore market noise and focus on fundamental analysis, focus on the accumulated wisdom of educational research rather than the latest pedagogical speculation. Your students deserve the educational equivalent of a diversified, low-cost, evidence-based portfolio—not high-risk bets on unproven theories.
These principles can guide educators through the uncertainties of academic life by applying the same rigorous, evidence-based thinking that drives successful long-term investing. The key is maintaining intellectual discipline, trusting research over intuition, and focusing on proven approaches that generate reliable educational returns over time.
About the Authors:
Dr. Chris Brown, PhD, CFP® is Professor of Finance and Endowed Fellow at Western Kentucky University, Chair of the Department of Finance, and co-author of research published in the Journal of Investing and Financial Services Review.
Dr. Ron A. Rhoades, JD, CFP® is Associate Professor of Finance and Co-Director of the Personal Financial Planning Program at Western Kentucky University. He is recipient of the Frankel Fiduciary Prize (2020) and author of Mastering the Science and Art of Investing.
Scholar Financial is a practice within XY Investment Solutions, LLC, providing fee-only, fiduciary financial planning and investment advice.
Contact: AdvisorInfo@ScholarFinancial.com
The opinions expressed in any commentary posted on this site are solely those of the individual author and do not necessarily reflect the views or opinions of XYIS. These opinions are based on information available at the time of posting and are subject to change without notice. XYIS does not commit to updating any posted positions or commentary to reflect subsequent developments. While the information and reasoning used to form these opinions are believed to be from reliable sources, XYIS does not verify this information, and no guarantee is provided regarding its accuracy, completeness, or validity. XYIS disclaims any and all liability for actions taken or not taken based on the content of this site. No warranty, express or implied, is given in connection with the content provided.
Past performance does not guarantee future results. All investments involve risk, including potential loss of principal. Factor premiums are not guaranteed and may not materialize as expected.
Consult with qualified financial advisors before making investment decisions.
